Beyond MAGA: Perceptions of Trump's Leadership
In January, More in Common released the most comprehensive study to date of the Americans who voted for President Trump in November 2024. Beyond MAGA: A Profile of the Trump Coalition provides a detailed segmentation of these voters and their views on the major issues confronting our country and the world. This newsletter is part of a multi-part series on Beyond MAGA that examines how the source of President Trump’s power is his ability to play different roles for supporters across his coalition.
An op-ed on President Trump’s leadership was also published in The Atlantic by the study’s authors Stephen Hawkins and Daniel Yudkin.
Learn more about the four types of Trump voters: MAGA Hardliners, Anti-Woke Conservatives, Mainline Republicans, and the Reluctant Right at beyondmaga.us.
Watch our short video about the MAGA Hardliners (29% of Trump voters), the fiery core of Trump’s base. MAGA Hardliners are fiercely loyal, deeply religious, and animated by a sense that America is in an existential struggle between good and evil, with God firmly on their side.
Introduction
“I voted for Trump because he is a natural, he is a leader. All the stuff that they threw at him, he just shook it off...that’s a lot of pressure, and he hung in there.”
Sam, MAGA Hardliner
Age 76 • Black man • Lancaster, South Carolina
To understand the coalition Donald Trump assembled, we must see him through the eyes of the 77 million Americans who voted for him: what he represents to them, the role he plays in their lives, and why so many view him as the answer to this period of perceived American decline.
What emerges is not a single, consistent picture but rather a set of overlapping images, each reflecting something different that his supporters see in him. It is precisely this ability to play different roles that is the source of Trump’s power.
In Beyond MAGA, we explore what that power looks like in practice: why his supporters chose him, what their different motivations reveal about the coalition he has assembled, and what drives their loyalty one year into his presidency.
Key Takeaways:
1. Leadership defines Trump’s appeal
When describing Trump in their own words, “leader” is the most common word his supporters use. Indeed, nearly three quarters of Trump voters (73 percent) believe he is “the best leader the Republican Party has had in my lifetime.” Many even view Trump more positively than the Republican Party itself: a third of his voters (29 percent) say they are more of a “Trump supporter than a Republican.”
“I like the fact that even if people don’t like him, he still stands by what he believes and he’s not somebody that goes along to get along. That’s why I like him as a leader. He doesn’t go with the popular opinion. He’s going to do what he wants”
Danielle, Mainline Republican
Age 28 • Black woman • Seagonville, Texas
Perceptions of Trump as a leader are reinforced by his combative style and a sense that he has the strength not to back down in the face of opposition. For many in his coalition, this willingness to fight signals the kind of toughness they believe is necessary to challenge entrenched interests and solve America’s problems.
Many of Trump’s supporters express an affinity for the president unmatched by any other public figure. When asked, for example, “Who is the best American alive?” almost a quarter (23 percent) of his supporters say Trump—more than quadruple the rate of any of the next-most popular individuals.
2. Motivations for supporting Trump vary across the coalition
While perceptions of Trump as a leader are shared across his coalition, the reasons supporters give for voting for him vary across groups. MAGA Hardliners are motivated by a strong personal loyalty, with seven in ten (63 percent) saying they are simply “strong supporters of Donald Trump.” Anti-Woke Conservatives, by contrast, are more policy-driven: a plurality (41 percent) say they had reservations about Trump but agreed with his policies.
Mainline Republicans are more divided, with a third (33 percent) citing policy agreement despite misgivings, and nearly as many (32 percent) expressing strong personal support. Finally, the Reluctant Right is more likely than any other cohort to say they voted for Trump because he was “less bad” than the alternative (39 percent). Taken together, these patterns suggest that Trump’s coalition is held together less by a single shared rationale than by a patchwork of distinct motivations.
“I just like his policies. I like a lot of his ideas, and people say things and never follow up. He tries to get things done. They stop him at every turn, but he tries to get things done.”
Fernando, MAGA Hardliner
Age 38 • Black man • Houston, Texas
3. One year in, Trump's coalition holds firm
As of January 2026, one year into Trump's presidency, most of his coalition remained “confident” or “very confident” in their choice. The one exception to this was the Reluctant Right, a quarter (25 percent) of whom had begun to say they “regret” their vote choice.
“I still support my decision to vote for Trump. He has come through on many promises he made and I know for long term change to happen there will be short-term growing pains.”
Jill, Mainline Republican
Age 47 • White woman • Oregon, Wisconsin
This broad resilience is reflected in how supporters evaluate Trump’s policies. There is far more variation between cohorts than between issue areas: for example, MAGA Hardliners give Trump “As” virtually across the board; Mainline Republicans give a mix of “Bs” and “Cs”; and the Reluctant Right give exclusively “Ds” and “Fs.” This lack of differentiation across issues suggests voters are not making fine-grained distinctions about particular policies, but rather applying a general assessment uniformly. The one exception is the Anti-Woke Conservatives, who show more nuance, giving Trump an “A” on immigration but “Cs” on trade and healthcare, with “Bs” on most other issues.
When examining specific issues, Trump receives his highest marks on immigration (86% approval), foreign policy (80%), and improving government efficiency (79%), while healthcare presents a challenge, with a 69% average approval from Trump voters.
Conclusion: The limits of Trump's coalition
Successful political leadership involves assembling and holding together broad coalitions. This has also been Trump’s political strength. But it is also his coalition’s vulnerability.
Trump possesses an uncanny ability to “read the crowd”—a skill that has been honed in WWE arenas, reality TV sets, and campaign podiums. He can be what they want him to be: a projection of their fears and aspirations; an avatar of their worldview. But beneath that shared conviction lies a more complex picture. His supporters were attracted to him for different reasons and one year in, they are evaluating his presidency through those different lenses.
For now, that diversity of motivation has proven a source of strength rather than weakness. Trump’s coalition holds, but gaps are emerging. While Trump’s grades on key issue areas remain strong, the variation in how the different types of Trump voters grade his performance suggests that Trump’s ability to be all things to all people has limits.
What unites Trump’s diverse coalition of MAGA Hardliners, Anti-Woke Conservatives, Mainline Republicans, and the Reluctant Right may not be enough to unite them as a governing coalition. How Trump navigates those differences will shape not just the future of the coalition, but of the country.
To read the full chapter on President Trump’s leadership and the rest of the Beyond MAGA report, visit BeyondMAGA.us. To hear directly from the researchers behind the report, watch our Beyond MAGA launch webinar here.
Help us make this newsletter better!
We’re looking to connect with our readers to understand what draws you to this newsletter and what you find most valuable. Your feedback will help us shape future content. Please take our four-question survey to weigh in. Want to share more? Email usmedia@moreincommon.com. We’d love to chat!
We can’t do this without you!
MIC regularly conducts research that sheds light on both cross-group misperceptions and common ground. Consider supporting our work by making a donation.
This article was very useful for helping me understand more about why Trump continues to hold onto the support of millions of Americans, even in the face of increasing chaos. It's also a great reminder of how much variation there is among people's motivations for supporting any candidate. We don't really know any particular person's perspective unless we ask them about it. That goes for people who lean left, too...as well as the 45% of Americans who identify as Independent.
Framing our US political situation as a binary fight between "Red" & "Blue" is a serious problem. It may produce more viewers or followers (if that's what's most important to you), but it's not helpful for moving us forward as a country. We need more of this kind of thoughtful consideration of how differently we think.
This article conveys one perspective, but as with virtually any study on human behavior, it is subject to doing so in a vacuum. For example, from where does MAGA loyalists get their news? What is their base of perspective and reality? Of course, these same questions apply to non-MAGA and anti-MAGA as well, i.e., all of us. This question is being further complicated by the influence of Ai.
What these complicated topics continually bring me back to is, what is happening to our sense of decency and shared humanity? Why are we allowing falsehoods to shape our reality? Why are we choosing to be polarized? Why are we discarding the lessons of the Golden Rule?
Deep down, we innately know what to do, but the noise has gotten the best of us. We don’t have a political ideology problem as much as we have a consciousness problem.